World Carrot Museum - carrots logo

History of the Carrot Part Two

From Medicine to Food  A.D. 200 to 1500

Chapters in the history rooms:

History Page 1 - A Brief Timeline
History Page 2 - Neolithic to AD 200 - Origins and development
History Page 3 - AD 200 to 1500 - From Medicine to Food
History Page 4 - 1500 to date   - Evolution and Improvement  - the modern carrot evolves.
History Page 5 - Explores, in some detail the theories of the road to domestication and the origin of Orange Carrots
History Page 6 - Takes an in depth look of the role of carrots in World War Two, reviving its popularity


The name Carota for the garden Carrot is found first in the writings of Athenaeus (A.D. 200), and in the book on cookery by Apicius Czclius.  It was Galen the Greek physician at the court of Marcus Aurelius (second century A.D.) who named the wild carrot Daucus pastinaca  (adding the name Daucus) to distinguish the Carrot from the Parsnip, though confusion remained steadfast until botanist Linnaeus set the record straight in the 18th century with his system of plant classification. The Greeks called the carrot Philon or Philtron from their word philo that means loving. However, the carrot's Latin name Daucus carota most influenced its present name that came from the French who named it carotte.

Galen said that the wild carrot "is less fit to be eaten than the cultivated variety".


AD 512  The Greek Herbal of Dioscorides: Illustrated by a Byzantine A.D. 512. - First reference to Orange Carrot - Diosdcorides Codex Vindobonensis Medicus Greacus. (Austrian facsimiles from 1965, together with commentary - studied at the Royal Botanical Gardens Library, Kew Gardens, England).

Greek physician Pedanius Dioscorides  catalogued over 600 medicinal plant species and their possible medical uses, during his first century travels as a roman army doctor and who accurately describes the modern carrot. He compiled an extensive listing of medicinal herbs and their virtues in about 70 A.D.  Originally written in Greek, Dioscorides' herbal was later translated into Latin as De Materia Medica. It remained the standard reference and authority on medicinal plants for over 1500 years. 

 

Byzantine Illustration of Orange Carrot ad 512
Original Script Illustration

Folio 312 (shown above right) clearly is an orange rooted carrot. The translation of the associated text reads:

"111,52 Daucus carota var, silvestris and D Carota L., Wild and Cultivated Carrot

1. The Wild Carrot: but some call it ceras. It has leaves like those of the carrot but wider and somewhat bitter, an upright stem that is rough and that has an umbel like that of dill on which there are white flowers, and in the middle there is something small and purplish, as if it were nap on woollen cloth; the root is as thick as a finger, a span long, aromatic, and edible when boiled.

2. When drunk or even when applied, its seed sets the menses going, it is suitable for those that pass water painfully and with difficulty, for those with edemata, for pleurisy in potions, and for bites and strokes of wild animals. They say that reptiles do not harm people who have taken it in advance; it also aids conception. As for the root, it, too is diuretic, aphrodisiac, and expels embryos/fetuses when used as a pessary. The leaves ground and applied with honey, clear cancerous sores completely.

The cultivated carrot, which is more edible, is suitable for the same purposes, but it acts more weakly."

Dioscorides also talked about Water Plantain which can be "used to stop colic and dysentery when drunk with an equal amount of Daucus."

A second folio (09 88) refers to the Cretan Carrot

" 111, 72 Athamanta cretensis L.,Daucos

1. Daucos: there is one kind called Cretan, having leaves like those of fennel but smaller and finer, a stem that is one span tall, an umbel like that of coriander, and white flowers; they cByzantine Illustration of Daucoscontain seed that is white, rough, pungent when chewed, and fragrant; the root is a finger thick and one span long.  (span = distance from tip of thumb to tip of small finger when hand is outstretched, about 5-7inches) It grows in rocky and sunny places. And there is another kind that nearly resembles wild celery; it is spicy and fragrant, and it tastes pungent and hot. The Cretan in superior.

2. The third kind resembles coriander in foliage and it has white flowers. Its top and fruit are similar to the dill's, the umbel is like that of carrot, it is full longish seed like cumin and it is pungent.

The seed of all of them warms; when drunk, it draws out the menstrual period, embryos and fetuses, and urine, it relieves colic, and it allays chronic coughs; it comes to the aid of people bitten by poisonous spiders when drunk with wine, and it disperses swellings when plastered on. All of them are used for their seed, but the Cretan is also used for its root, which is mostly drunk with wine as an antidote to poisonous animals."

It should also be noted that Parsnip is referenced as a separate plant (Pastinaca Sativus) indicating a clear distinction with carrot.

It is interesting when one reads the what the Herbalists of the 15th century say about carrot and how so many refer to carrot being used for animal bites,  urination problems, conception aids and methods of expelling embryos and after birth.  Clearly using this source from 1000 years earlier.  Read about the Herbalists and how they recommended carrots here.

Another translation states - Dioscorides wrote "Ye root ye thickness of a finger, a span long, sweet-smelling, edible being sodden [boiled]. Of this ye seed being drank...and it is good for ye [painful discharge of urine] in potions, and for ye bitings and strokes of venomous beasts; they say also, that they which take it before hand shall take no wrong of wilde beasts. It co-operates also to conception, and it also being [diuretic], both provoketh [poison], and being applied; but the leaves being beaten small with honey, and laid on, doth cleanse rapidly spreading destructive ulceration of soft tissues." He recommended the seeds of Wild Carrot for the relief of urinary retention, to stimulate menstruation and to "wake up the genital virtue." 


By the eighth century people had been using herbs as medical tools for over four thousand years. Herbalism and medicine were essentially the same practice.

After the fall of Rome, gardens and vegetables are rarely mentioned again until 795 ad, when King Charlemagne enacted a charter or capitulary entitled "Capitulare de villis vel curtis imperii" (Of imperial lands and imperial courts), in chapter 70 of which appears a list of 90 plants and fruit trees recommended to cultivate in the gardens of the Frankish Empire, which covered western and central Europe. Carrots (carvitas) are found in the list of vegetables recommended for cultivation by Charlemagne.  Note - Pastinacas (Parsnip) were also shown as a separate plant.

Charlemagne's edict tells his subjects what he expects of them:

"We desire that they have in the garden all the herbs namely, the lily, roses, fenugreek, costmary, sage, rue, southernwood, cucumbers, pole beans, cumin, rosemary, caraway, chick pea, squill, iris, arum, anise, coloquinth, chicory, animi, laserwort, lettuce, black cumin, garden rocket, nasturtium, burdock, pennyroyal, alexander, parsley, celery, lovage, sabine tree, dill, fennel, endive, dittany, black mustard, savory, curly mint, water mint, horse mint, tansy, catnip, feverfew, poppy, beet sugar, marshmallows, high mallows, carrots, parsnips, oraches, amaranths, kohlrabis, cabbages, onions, chives, leeks, radishes, shallots, garlics, madder, artichokes or fulling thistles, big beans, field peas, coriander, chervil, capper spurge, clary."

(Citation: Helen Morganthau Fox, Gardening with Herbs for Flavor and Fragrance (New York: The Macmillan Company, 1933, reprinted Dover Publications, Inc., 1970), p. 45.)

Charlemagne welcomed new fruits and vegetables into his royal gardens and set aside an area for growing carrots, though their flavour did not win them a great deal of acceptance there either. To lessen their appeal, the purple carrots turned brown when cooked. Worse still, any liquid and foods cooked in the same pot also turned brown.

 

Alcuin (ca. 732-804), who was an Anglo-Latin scholar asked - "What is an herb?" According to legend, he posed this question to his pupil Charlemagne, the 8th century ruler of France. The King's reply was, "The friend of physicians and the praise of cooks." That an herb should be called "the friend of physicians" might seem odd to twenty first century readers, but Charlemagne's answer was certainly true of his time.

The medicinal properties of the carrot were already well established. You can find more about the wonderful health properties on the nutrition pages.

In 10th Century  carrot consumption is traced to the hill people of Afghanistan (ad 900), who were sun-worshippers and believed that eating orange or yellow coloured foods instilled a sense of righteousness. People also ate yellow and purple conical tap root varieties of carrots in Pakistan. At this time Arab merchants traversing the trade routes of Africa, Arabia, and Asia brought seeds of this purple carrot back home with them. From their villages and cities along the coast of North Africa, Moors brought the carrot up into Spain and to the rest of Europe, probably from Afghanistan. Yellow and purple carrots are first recorded in Asia Minor and the Byzantine Empire (now Turkey) in the 10th century. This was a mutation which effectively removed the anthocyanins which gives the red/purple colour.

The Old English Herbarium (late10th C) takes its material from Pliny and other latin compilations and cites uses for carrot: 

"The pastinaca silvatica plant which is wild carrot or parsnip - For difficult childbirth and  For womens cleansing -

82. Wild Carrot of Parsnip (Daucus cartoa L, or Pastinaca sativa L, pastinaca sivatica, Feldmoru.

This plantm which is called pastinace silvatice or wild carrots, grows in sandy soils and hills.

1. If a woman has difficulty in giving birth, thae the plant we call pasticanna sivatica (willd carrot or parsnip), simmer it in water, and give it so that she can bathe herself with it. She will be healed.

2. For a woman's cleansing, take the same plant, pastinaca, simmer it in water, and when it is soft, mix it well and give it to drink. She will be cleansed."

 


It is known that purple or red and yellow carrots were cultivated in Iran and Arabia in the 10th century and in Syria in the 11th. By the 12th century carrots were reported in Spain, followed by Italy in the 13th, France, Germany and Holland by the 14th century.  English references occur in the 15th century.

11th Century

In About 1086, Ibn al Bassal an Islamic Botanist and scholar who lived in Seville, Spain from wrote a lengthy treatise on agronomy (Diwan al-filaha) “Libro de Agricultura” - The Book on Agriculture, a treatise on agriculture.

It is full of information on the cultivation of plants and trees, pharmacological data and many items on botany. Very little is known about his life. However, judging from the meaning of his Arabic name Ibn Bassal (i.e. the Son of the Onion Grower), he seems to be a learned agriculturalist from a farming family.

The book, though not a cookbook per se, it contains information about the different kinds of foodstuff and how to produce them and preserve them, in addition to the agricultural methods in cultivation, irrigation, pets control and land tilling in Andalusia in the 11th century. The treatise by Ibn Bassal is singular in that it contains no reference to earlier agronomists; it appears to be based exclusively on the personal experiences of the author, who is revealed as the most original and objective of all the Hispano-Arabic specialists.

The treatise was lost for many years until a mediaeval Castilian translation of it was discovered by Prof. Millis in the Cathedral Library of Toledo and extracts of it were published by him in 1942.

Bassal’s ancient text deals with all the fundamentals of horticulture and propagation. In Chapter XIII he deals with Garden plants - Rapes, carrots, radishes, garlic, onions, leeks, parsnip, capsicum (pimento), madder. The interesting feature of it is its character. It is matter of fact, practical, didactic, concise; there is no nonsense in it and no digressions on materia medica, no magic and no astrology.


Bodleian Scripts  - 11th Century

The late 11th century witnessed an intriguing script from Bury St Edmonds in England - MS Bodley 130 - a handwritten manuscript containing a copy of a much earlier Latin text; its illustrations are similarly inherited. The original illustrated text had been compiled in the late Roman period (4th or 5th century) relying on Greek sources.

Known as "Pseudo.-Apuleius, Dioscorides, Herbals (extracts); De virtutibus bestiarum in arte medicinae, in Latin and English",  St Augustine's Abbey, Canterbury; c. 1070-1100.  This apparently shows a diagram of an orange carrot, which, according to most other historical records did not appear until the 15th century. So another mystery in the origins of modern carrot. 

The script indicated that

 "It grows in stony places and mounds." and "For women who suffer at childbirth and are not purged. - With 'Herba pastinaca', cooked, together with the same water in which it was cooked, you take 30 peppercorns; mix together and give to drink; she will be purged.

The same recipe as written above also works against toothache."

Further evidence of the use, by the ancients of Pastinaca for both carrot and parsnip.
 

MS Bodley 130 - 11th century script - Pseudo Apuleian text

Much more background information, including a full translation of the script together with a larger photo are included on a separate page here.

 

Important Copyright Notice:

The image (left) appears with the kind permission of the Bodleian Library and is copyright and any use is restricted by law. Any unauthorised copying or reproduction will constitute an infringement of copyright.

The script is held by the Bodleian Library of Oxford University as part of its collection of illuminated mediaeval manuscripts.

 

Similar scripts - MS. Ashmole 1462 and MS Ashmole 1431 contain the same Pseudo-Apuleian text as MS. Bodl. 130, though with some slight variations in wording.

You will notice a typo! "Pasnatica" instead of "Pastinaca" - a typical transcription error in such scripts.  This again gives a remedy for toothache. Otherwise the same recipes and place names as in the MS Bodley script referred to above.

The carrot leaves and flower do look quite accurate and no doubt orange is the root colour! Click on photos for full picture - note this a large file and will take a while to download.

 

MS Ashmole 1431 - Bodelian Library Script
MS Ashmole 1431 - Pastinaca (Carrot) left

MS Ashmole 1462 Script - Pseudo Apuleian text
MS. Ashmole 1462 - Pastinaca Silvatica

Important Copyright Notice: The images (above) appear with the kind permission of the Bodleian Library and are copyright and any use is restricted by law. Any unauthorised copying or reproduction will constitute an infringement of copyright.

The script is held by the Bodleian Library of Oxford University as part of its collection of illuminated mediaeval manuscripts.

 


purple carrotsCenturies passed before the carrot received additional mention in historical literature.

In the 12th century there was a period of Arab expansion into the Middle East and Asia.

Moorish invaders (from Morocco) and then Arabian traders brought seeds of purple and a mutants yellow carrots to the Mediterranean via the coast of North Africa, along with spinach and aubergines. They quickly spread across Europe from Spain, into Holland, France and finally England. 

During that period the carrot travelled westward into the Mediterranean countries. Arab writer, in Spain Ibn al-Awam , citing a much older work (probably Ibn al Bassal an Islamic Botanist mentioned above) gave a definitive description of two varieties of carrots he encountered in the early part of the 12th century: a red one (probably purple) he says is tasty and juicy and the other, a yellow and green carrot, he calls coarser and of inferior flavour. Al-Awam writes that carrots were served with a dressing of oil and vinegar or added to vegetable mixtures and cereals, probably grains.

Al-Awam who lived in Andalusia, a region in southern Spain, noted that Arab travellers brought carrots from their homeland to the European continent. The curious carrot traversed the route eastward via European travellers and explorers to set its roots into India and the Far East during the 13th century. By the 14th century the Netherlands, France and Germany were introduced to the carrot. It took another century to reach England's shores during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I.

Henry Daniel 1315 (approx) - 1385 Although little is known of Daniel's life, a good deal can be deduced from his surviving works, which include translations of medical treatises from the Latin and an extensive herbal, De re Herbaria (1375). He must originally have been comparatively well-to-do, but later became poor and joined the Dominican Order.  It was probably after entering religion that he was able to get access to the many authorities which he consulted in the compilation of his herbal.

Daniel was a scholar of distinction and a student of medicine. He sought out works which, in many cases, must have been rare in English libraries, and his surviving translations are correct, clear, and forcibly expressed.  In his youth Daniel studied medicine for seven years and in his later life had a large garden at Stepney, London, in which he grew 252 different kinds of plants, a very large number for the period.

Carrots were named by Daniel in the list of habitats as - "growing in dry places, and in meers."


By the 13th century carrots were being grown in fields, orchards, gardens, and vineyards in Germany and France. At that time the plant was known also in China, where it was supposed to have come from Persia. Doctors in the Middle Ages prescribed carrots as a medicine for every possible affliction, from syphilis to dog bites! 

The curious carrot traversed the route eastward via European travellers and explorers to set its roots into India and the Far East during the 13th century.

The 14th century In approx 1350 it is known from archaeological evidence that they consumed a variety of vegetables, both grown in gardens and gathered in the wild in the British Isles. Vegetables known from Jorvík (modern York) or Dublin include carrots, parsnips, turnips, celery, spinach, wild celery, cabbage, radishes, fava beans, and peas.

In the Netherlands, France and Germany were introduced to the carrot. It took another century to reach England's shores during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I. carrots had spread across north-western Europe. Poor country dwelling folk used the roots for soups that formed the main staple diet.

In the 15th century the early orange varieties were introduced to England by Flemish refugees who grew them in quantity mainly in Kent and Surrey.  Several Herbalists mention "karettes" in their lists of roots for a garden.Gerard's Yellow Carrot 1633

Carrot is also mentioned by Italian cook Bartolomeo Sacchi (a.k.a Platina) in his dish "Cariota" - Here are some words and, and recipes of sorts, for both the carrot and the parsnip. He considers them simply variations of the same medicinally useful vegetable.

(From De Honesta Voluptate (On Honest Indulgence and Good Health), Bartolomeo Platina,  - On Right Pleasure and Good Health; Platina 1475, from the Milham translation).
 

"Cariota - Roast carrots in the coals, then peel them, cleaning off the ashes, and cut them up. Put in a dish with oil, vinegar and a bit of wine; scatter a few mild herbs on the top.

On the Carrot and Parsnip - There are two kinds of parsnip (probably parsnip and carrot).  Doctors say that the parsnip is white while the carrot is red or almost black.  Both are difficult to digest and of little and harsh nourishment. The parsnip should be boiled twice, with the first water thrown away, and cooked with lettuce the second time. Transferred from there to a dish and seasoned with salt, vinegar, coriander, and pepper, it is suitable to eat, for it settles cough, pleurisy, and dropsy, and arouses passion. It is even customary for it to be rolled in meal and fried in oil and fat when it has been hollowed out after the first boiling.
Carrot is seasoned in the same way as parsnip, but it is considered sweeter if cooked under warm ash and coals. When it is taken out, it should cool a little, be peeled, scraped entirely free of ash, cut up in bits and transferred in to a dish. Salt should be added, oil and vinegar sprinkled on, some condensed must or must added, and sweet spices sprinkled over. There is nothing more pleasant to eat than this. It is good for people in two respects, for it represses bile and moves the urine. In other ways it is harmful, as it is for liver, stomach, and spleen."


After Columbus' first visit to the Caribbean in 1492, the islands became the melting pot of the world with explorers from Europe, Asia, Africa, and America who each brought plants, animals, and customs from their homelands.

 


e mail symbol Next Page - The Carrot from 1500 to date carrot pointer


History Wild Carrot Today Nutrition Cultivation Recipes Trivia Fun Authors Cats Links Home